Professor Jacqueline D Lipton writes about cybernorms

24 September 2011 · Inlagt som Cybernorms av  

[This is a post from the Cybernorms.net blog, which is the English equivalent to Cybernormer.se. You can follow this link to read this post at its original URL.]

A recent article by Jacqueline D Lipton, Professor of Law; Associate Dean for Faculty  Development and Research; Co-Director, Center for Law, Technology, and the Arts, Case Western Reserve University School of Law, brings attention to the concept of cybernorms. The article is titled What Blogging Might Teach About CyberNorms and is published in The Akron Intellectual Property Journal, a scholarly legal publication of The University of Akron School of Law that produces an annual volume of two issues for use by scholars, practitioners, and judges. In a SSRN pre-publication there is an abstract of the article that give us the following information:

Since the dawn of the information age, scholars have debated the viability of regulating cyberspace. Early on, Professor Lawrence Lessig suggested that “code is law” online. Lessig and others also examined the respective regulatory functions of laws, code, market forces, and social norms. In recent years, with the rise of Web 2.0 interactive technologies, norms have taken center-stage as a regulatory modality online. The advantages of norms are that they can develop quickly by the communities that seek to enforce them, and they are not bound by geography. However, to date there has been scant literature dealing in any detail with specific online norms, and comparing them with other forms of regulation. This article reverses that trend by presenting a detailed case study of one developing norm in the blogosphere – the norm against “hijacking” a comment thread in a blog by hyperlinking, and thereby redirecting readers, to another blog. Using this case study, the article draws some conclusions about the relative advantages and disadvantages of norms as regulators. In particular, the author concludes that too much weight is often placed on vague and opaque norms in online interactions. It advocates future emphasis on more well developed and clearly expressed norms.

The article constitutes one important contribution to the ongoing scholarly discussion about interactions and coexistence of legal rules and social norms online. It both lays out some fundamental theoretical considerations and illustrates the complexity through an interesting example. Liptons production regarding cyberlaw and cybernorms in this article and elsewhere is well worth studying.

Spara och/eller dela med dig:
  • Maila artikeln!
  • Skriv ut artikeln!
  • Facebook
  • Bloggy
  • TwitThis
  • Pusha
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg

Kommentarer

Lämna gärna en kommentar!




  • RSS Cybernorms.net

    • The Research Bay closed, for this time 12 May 2012
      At 0900 o’clock Saturday morning local time we closed the survey that we have had promoted on The Pirate Bay, called The Research Bay. After 72 hours we’ve got almost 100 000 answers – covering people of all ages from all over the world! This gives the research community a great pool of data and […]
    • The Research Bay, reloaded 9 May 2012
      Welcome to Cybernorms.net, the blog of the Cybernorms Research Group. We are a group of researchers mainly based at the Department of Sociology of Law at Lund University, Sweden, affiliated with the Lund University Internet Institute. During three days in April last year the Cybernorms Research Group conducted a big survey study called The Research […]
    • Releasing data on online anonymity 3 May 2012
      The week has been a good week in the media for the LUii affiliated Cybernorms research project. With Måns Svensson, head of the research group, in the lead, we released data from our latest follow up survey on file sharing and online anonymity. We found that when compared to figures from late 2009, 40% more […]
    • Conference on norms: session on law, language and the mind 25 April 2012
      The international conference on norms in Lund, Sweden, is now in its second of two days. The official name is The Normative Anatomy of Society – Relations Between Norms and Law in the 21st Century. Its is arranged by the Department for Sociology of Law at Lund University. Picture from the morning plenary. From the […]
    • Conference on norms in April 6 February 2012
      There is a conference coming up 24-25 April at Lund University in Sweden. If you are academically into norms from any perspective, you should probably check it out. The name of the conference is The Normative Anatomy of Society. Relations Between Norms and Law in the 21st Century and it deals with “to promote an […]